I agree that UPI should be taxed. It only makes sense for the infrastructure to develop better. My problem is with the nefarious way it was introduced to people. The push for digital payment came right during demonetisation. Citizens were left stripped of their own money in the name of cleaning the system. The ATMs weren't prepared to dispose the changed currency. People were made to believe that they must use UPI by default in today's day and age as it so easy and free. And now when the entire nation is hooked on the system, bringing in a taxation seems manipulative.
Both pieces are brilliant. On the UPI bit, one point in favour of removing a switch monopoly and introducing small charges is that it will fund innovation and cybersecurity investments. The trouble is - if the government switch is priced very cheaply given they have no profit imperative, how will private operators survive? There needs to be a level playing field.
The article addresses good points. Not to dwell in the past is a good point... but... yet there are few i disagree-quote '.... Back in 1947, what did India mean to the many millions living their lives in small villages of various princely states, in deep forests or in provinces ruled by the Raj? Precious little....' that is not true at all... many people were never schooled in Indian history, but the ones who were always knew the regional cooperation of different kingdoms ... that your quote forgets india was vast kingdoms with its own strong armies that fought real battles since 700AD when mughals& europeans invaded. India was not some poor villages, ruled by raj. but after 1857( a thousand years of collective fighting) the east india company years the laws& transaction of trade changed to impoverish all kingdoms.... then the movement itself changed. Inclusion was never a problem in Bharath.
The younger gen dont need braggings of kingdoms that fought over 1300 years but they dont need to think they descended from unknown farms or forests with no skills or knowledge... that the farms& forests and towns held reasonably advanced community that cared & knew to fight and give shelter to persecuted other from different lands& religions remains important.
150 years had finest minds indeed... but to call common man/woman by bad vocabulary derac#%** ed is bad. There are few not very fine in all places in the globe. but the represented masses, the common men& women are not the bad ones. ... the system needs to cognise its own strength than highlight the bad ones with poor labels... the example of youth making bad labels into campaign of their plight is a very sad issue.
in a new world new changes bring new challenges.Youth definitely require better systems, highlights& process to find complimentary labels instead of ugly names.
This is so heartfelt and lovely, RSJ. The move from janini to child is beautiful framing: reverence leaves room only for pride, but a child you love enough to worry about is one you can be honest with. That's the register India at this age/stage most needs and rarely gets. And your second point — that we "become smaller without losing any territory" when we narrow who belongs — is so aptly put.
Coincidentally, I found myself reaching for the same handholds a week ago, combining some policy ideas together with values — and arriving, without planning to, at the same closing Tagore. Different route, same point: the mind without fear, the circle kept wide. In case it's of interest to A/U's readers, here's the link: [https://rajeshachanta.substack.com/p/dear-india]. Happy Independence Day to you and Pranay.
I agree that UPI should be taxed. It only makes sense for the infrastructure to develop better. My problem is with the nefarious way it was introduced to people. The push for digital payment came right during demonetisation. Citizens were left stripped of their own money in the name of cleaning the system. The ATMs weren't prepared to dispose the changed currency. People were made to believe that they must use UPI by default in today's day and age as it so easy and free. And now when the entire nation is hooked on the system, bringing in a taxation seems manipulative.
Both pieces are brilliant. On the UPI bit, one point in favour of removing a switch monopoly and introducing small charges is that it will fund innovation and cybersecurity investments. The trouble is - if the government switch is priced very cheaply given they have no profit imperative, how will private operators survive? There needs to be a level playing field.
The article addresses good points. Not to dwell in the past is a good point... but... yet there are few i disagree-quote '.... Back in 1947, what did India mean to the many millions living their lives in small villages of various princely states, in deep forests or in provinces ruled by the Raj? Precious little....' that is not true at all... many people were never schooled in Indian history, but the ones who were always knew the regional cooperation of different kingdoms ... that your quote forgets india was vast kingdoms with its own strong armies that fought real battles since 700AD when mughals& europeans invaded. India was not some poor villages, ruled by raj. but after 1857( a thousand years of collective fighting) the east india company years the laws& transaction of trade changed to impoverish all kingdoms.... then the movement itself changed. Inclusion was never a problem in Bharath.
The younger gen dont need braggings of kingdoms that fought over 1300 years but they dont need to think they descended from unknown farms or forests with no skills or knowledge... that the farms& forests and towns held reasonably advanced community that cared & knew to fight and give shelter to persecuted other from different lands& religions remains important.
150 years had finest minds indeed... but to call common man/woman by bad vocabulary derac#%** ed is bad. There are few not very fine in all places in the globe. but the represented masses, the common men& women are not the bad ones. ... the system needs to cognise its own strength than highlight the bad ones with poor labels... the example of youth making bad labels into campaign of their plight is a very sad issue.
in a new world new changes bring new challenges.Youth definitely require better systems, highlights& process to find complimentary labels instead of ugly names.
This is so heartfelt and lovely, RSJ. The move from janini to child is beautiful framing: reverence leaves room only for pride, but a child you love enough to worry about is one you can be honest with. That's the register India at this age/stage most needs and rarely gets. And your second point — that we "become smaller without losing any territory" when we narrow who belongs — is so aptly put.
Coincidentally, I found myself reaching for the same handholds a week ago, combining some policy ideas together with values — and arriving, without planning to, at the same closing Tagore. Different route, same point: the mind without fear, the circle kept wide. In case it's of interest to A/U's readers, here's the link: [https://rajeshachanta.substack.com/p/dear-india]. Happy Independence Day to you and Pranay.